Herring
Tested serving
- Any typical portion
Herring is Low FODMAP at any typical portion, a plain oily fish that is protein and fat.
- Plain herring is protein and fat with negligible carbohydrate, so it is low at any typical portion.
Grill, bake or pan-fry it with lemon and fresh herbs, and watch pickled or sauced versions where onion or garlic can change the picture.
Why herring is rated low
Plain herring is low FODMAP at "Any typical portion", the tested serving, and no FODMAP subgroup is recorded for it. It is an oily fish made of protein and fat, so there is no fermentable carbohydrate in the flesh for the rating to turn on. The complication with herring is that it is rarely eaten plain. A lot of the herring people buy comes pickled with sliced onion, bathed in a cream sauce, or served on rye bread, and each of those can take a low fish to a higher meal.
What changes your risk
- Serving size Low holds at "Any typical portion". That is a per-serving verdict, so it covers a normal helping rather than an open-ended one.
- Pickling brine with onion Jarred pickled herring is very often packed with sliced onion in the brine. Onion's FODMAPs are water-soluble and can move into the brine and the fish sitting in it, so lifting the onion out does not fully reset the jar.
- Cream and dairy sauces Herring in a cream or creamy dill sauce brings in ordinary cream or milk-based ingredients, which add FODMAPs that plain herring does not have.
- The bread underneath Herring is classically served on rye bread or crispbread. Rye in ordinary bread amounts is high in FODMAPs, so the base can matter more than the fish on it.
- Smoking and salting Kippers, smoked herring and salted herring are still plain fish, and the curing itself does not change the rating. Check the label for added onion, garlic or other flavourings.
What else works
Mackerel, sardines, salmon and trout are oily fish in the same place as herring, low with no FODMAP subgroup recorded, and canned sardines or mackerel in oil or plain water are easy pantry swaps. The versions that are NOT the same as plain herring are pickled herring packed with onion, herring in cream or sour sauces, herring salads mixed with onion, and herring served on ordinary rye bread. To get the sharp, pickled flavour without onion, dress plain or smoked herring with vinegar, a little sugar, dill and chives, and serve it on gluten free bread, traditional sourdough spelt bread, or boiled potato instead of rye.
How to keep it low
Read the label before buying herring in a jar or tin: plain, smoked, or in oil or tomato with no onion or garlic listed is the version that matches the low rating. Fresh herring is best cooked simply, grilled or pan-fried with salt, pepper and lemon, and its oily flesh crisps nicely under a hot grill. To make a quick low FODMAP pickled herring at home, cover plain or salted herring fillets in a brine of vinegar, water, sugar, peppercorns, bay leaf and dill, and use chives or the green tops of spring onions where a recipe calls for onion. Serve it with boiled potatoes, cucumber and a spoonful of lactose-free yoghurt mixed with dill.
Common questions
is herring low fodmap
Yes. Plain herring is low FODMAP at "Any typical portion", and no FODMAP subgroup is recorded for it.
is pickled herring low fodmap
Often not as sold, because jarred pickled herring is usually packed with sliced onion and onion's FODMAPs move into the brine. A version pickled without onion, or a homemade brine with vinegar, sugar and dill, keeps it low.
are kippers low fodmap
Kippers are smoked herring, and smoking does not change the rating, so plain kippers fit "Any typical portion". Check the label for any added onion or garlic flavouring.
can i eat herring on rye bread on a low fodmap diet
The herring is fine, but ordinary rye bread is high in FODMAPs. Serve it on gluten free bread, traditional sourdough spelt bread or boiled potato instead.
Try FODMAP Foods
Scan any food with your camera, search every rating in this list, and see your safe portion before you eat.
Learn more
Where this rating comes from
Herring is rated from published lab measurements of its FODMAP content, using the low, moderate and high cutoffs of Varney et al. (2017).
Feedback sent through the FODMAP Foods app has led to changes in this list.
Sources
- Fructan and free fructose content of common Australian vegetables and fruit. Muir et al. (2007), J. Agricultural and Food Chemistry 55(16):6619-6627.
- Measurement of short-chain carbohydrates in common Australian vegetables and fruits by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Muir et al. (2009), J. Agricultural and Food Chemistry 57(2):554-565.
- Quantification of fructans, galacto-oligosaccharides and other short-chain carbohydrates in processed grains and cereals. Biesiekierski et al. (2011), J. Human Nutrition and Dietetics 24(2):154-176.
- Dietary sorbitol and mannitol: food content and distinct absorption patterns between healthy individuals and patients with irritable bowel syndrome. Yao et al. (2014), J. Human Nutrition and Dietetics 27(Suppl 2):263-275.
- FODMAPs: food composition, defining cutoff values and international application. Varney et al. (2017), J. Gastroenterology and Hepatology 32(Suppl 1):53-61. Supplies the low, moderate and high cutoffs used on this page.
Informational only, not medical advice. Individual tolerance varies. Talk to a healthcare professional or a dietitian for personal guidance.